Are Antidepressants Really Working, or Are We Missing the Bigger Picture?
I Received an Email About Antidepressants. And It Made Me Ask a Rather Important Question.
What if treating depression requires us to look beyond the prescription pad?
A friend recently forwarded me an interesting email. Attached to it was a rather provocative article titled:
“I’m an NHS psychiatrist – and I’m not convinced antidepressants work.”
Naturally, the headline caught my attention. Not because I am particularly fond of controversial headlines, but because the subject concerns millions of people who wake up every morning trying to make sense of their own minds.
The article featured Professor Joanna Moncrieff, a practising NHS psychiatrist and Professor of Critical and Social Psychiatry at University College London. In her November 10, 2026, commentary published in The Telegraph, she questioned the effectiveness of antidepressants, challenged the familiar chemical imbalance explanation of depression, and raised concerns about emotional numbness, side effects and withdrawal.
I read it with curiosity. And then I read it again.
Because, somewhere between the medical terminology and the uncomfortable questions, there was an important conversation worth having.
Are We Treating Depression, or Just Its Symptoms?
For years, we have heard that depression is linked to a chemical imbalance in the brain, particularly involving serotonin. This explanation has become so familiar that many people accept it as the complete story.
But human psychology is rarely that straightforward.
What happens when someone's depression is rooted in years of emotional neglect? What about someone struggling with financial insecurity, an unhealthy relationship, childhood trauma, grief, loneliness or an environment that constantly drains their emotional resources?
Can we really expect a prescription to resolve circumstances that continue to hurt someone every single day?
Professor Moncrieff challenges the assumption that depression is simply a biological malfunction that medication can correct. She argues that the serotonin-deficiency explanation has not been established by convincing scientific evidence.
This is an important distinction: questioning the chemical imbalance narrative does not mean questioning the reality of depression.
Depression is real. The suffering is real. The exhaustion, loss of interest, hopelessness and difficulty functioning are real.
What deserves further examination is how we understand the condition and whether the treatment offered is addressing the person's actual needs.
When Feeling Better Doesn't Necessarily Mean Feeling Whole
One of the concerns raised in the article is emotional blunting.
Some people taking antidepressants report feeling less emotionally responsive. They may experience reduced sadness, but also less excitement, affection, pleasure or enthusiasm.
Imagine being able to get through the day but feeling strangely disconnected from the things that once made it meaningful.
For some individuals, this reduction in emotional intensity may be helpful. For others, it can become an unwanted side effect.
And this brings us to a question worth asking:
Is the goal simply to reduce emotional pain, or is it to help someone regain the ability to experience life fully?
These are not necessarily competing goals. Sometimes reducing overwhelming symptoms is precisely what allows a person to begin rebuilding their life. But treatment should also consider the person's quality of life, emotional experiences and individual response.
The Missing Conversation: What Is Happening in Someone's Life?
Perhaps the most thought-provoking part of this discussion is the emphasis on circumstances.
We sometimes approach depression as though it exists independently of the person experiencing it.
But consider this:
A woman who has spent years feeling unheard may not need another lecture about positive thinking.
A young person dealing with relentless academic pressure may not simply need to be told to sleep earlier.
Someone experiencing grief may not need their sadness treated as an inconvenience.
And a person living in an emotionally exhausting environment may need more than symptom management.
They may need safety, meaningful relationships, practical support, psychotherapy and an opportunity to change the circumstances contributing to their distress.
This does not mean every case of depression has an identifiable external cause. Nor does it mean psychological support can replace medication in every situation.
It means that the person must remain at the centre of treatment.
So, Do Antidepressants Actually Work?
Here, I would like to pause before drawing any dramatic conclusions.
Professor Moncrieff presents a strongly critical position, but her opinion should not be mistaken for an established medical consensus.
Research has found that antidepressants can help many people, particularly in moderate to severe depression, although their average benefits, individual responses and potential side effects vary. They are not a universal solution, and neither are they useless simply because their precise biological mechanisms remain incompletely understood.
The important question is not whether every person should take antidepressants or whether nobody should take them.
It is whether the potential benefits outweigh the risks for a particular individual.
Medication decisions deserve proper clinical assessment, informed discussion and follow-up. Anyone considering changing or stopping antidepressants should speak with their prescribing clinician first. Stopping suddenly can cause withdrawal symptoms and may increase the risk of relapse.
Perhaps We Need a More Human Approach to Mental Health
My biggest takeaway from the article was not that antidepressants should be abandoned.
It was that we should become more curious about the people taking them.
We need to ask better questions:
What happened before the depression began?
What is keeping the person emotionally overwhelmed?
Are they receiving adequate psychological support?
Are their living conditions contributing to their distress?
Is their medication helping, and are they experiencing unwanted effects?
Do they feel heard by the professionals treating them?
Mental healthcare should not become a revolving door where someone receives a diagnosis, a prescription and a follow-up appointment without anyone genuinely exploring their circumstances.
Sometimes medication can provide valuable relief. Sometimes therapy can open doors that medication alone cannot. Sometimes practical changes and social support are essential. Often, a combination of approaches offers the best way forward.
And perhaps that is where we should be directing more of our attention.
A Little Food for Thought
I am grateful to my friend for forwarding this article because it reminded me of something we can easily overlook:
A person is not a prescription. A diagnosis is not a complete biography. And depression is not a story that can always be understood through brain chemistry alone.
We should neither romanticise suffering nor dismiss medical treatment. We should not shame people who need medication, and we should not silence those who have experienced difficult side effects.
Instead, we should encourage informed conversations, compassionate treatment and the freedom to ask questions.
If you are taking antidepressants and they are helping you, that experience matters.
If you are taking them and struggling with their effects, that experience matters too.
And if you are someone who has been battling depression without knowing where to begin, please remember that you deserve professional support, not judgement.
Maybe the most important question isn't simply whether antidepressants work.
Maybe it is whether we are doing enough to understand the human being who needs help in the first place.
See you soon.









Comments
Post a Comment